Subject: Questions & Answers

Let's play some roulette then my friend! The russian style, I mean

Point taken. I have been on the losing end of many upsets. In turn I relegated and all is happy

You have lost 2 matches this season, one in the league and one in CL !

And if you still win..

Man, there were so many unfair draws and so many strange games... I would prefer if you focused on my tactics or lineup. I would try something out there.

Strange results happen far tooo frequently. This is the problem. Having a HUGE advantage over your opponent doesn't give you enoght change of success.

Playing with a bad formation/tactic doesn't give you enough penalty. Tactic in this game seems to be totally useless. Only having stronger players count, and often yet it is not enough.

*chance

The show must go on:

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...

Question: 3 matches is a raw like this.. isn't that "a bit" strange?

If you want to prove that the match engine generates too many upsets, you need to stop picking out individual games and instead show us an unbiased analysis of a large number of games.

For example, examine your last 100 games and determine what percentage were clear upsets (both for and against your team). When you've got an actual number for upset chance, then we can discuss if it's too high.

Indeed he could do that, but it would be a waste of time, when the dev's are already supposed to have loads of tests made. So it would be great if they showed us some clear numbers -no sensitive data, of course-, in order to prove/refute that everything is working as wished

Good point.

Higuera is right.
However, just a few data about this season:

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: probably LOSS, Result: DRAW, Judgment: OK

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: DRAW, Judgment: BAD

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: more probably WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: 50-50, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: more probably WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

vs Felsina
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: more probably WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

vs Sbocco Rosso
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: DRAW, Judgment: BAD

vs Lupi Roma
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: more probably WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

vs Nanto
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: LOSS, Judgment: BAD

vs Cribbio
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

vs pingui
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

vs Ravenous Geckoes Roma
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: DRAW, Judgment: BAD

vs Viareggio
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: DRAW, Judgment: BAD

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

ppm.powerplaymanager.com/...
Supposed: WIN, Result: DRAW, Judgment: BAD

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: WIN, Judgment: OK

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: LOSS, Judgment: BAD

soccer.powerplaymanager.c...
Supposed: WIN, Result: LOSS, Judgment: BAD

20 matches (I selected all league/cups matches excluding matches versus: bots and IV/III league teams):
strange results on 8 matches, that is 40%!!!

I could take statistics of last season too, but I'd require me a lot of time for more or less same results.

Furthermore, a few posts ago I posted this match:
soccer.powerplaymanager.c...

This is a completely ABSURD match (for arguments, see my post)!! It should happen not more than once every 1.000 matches! But it happens much more frequently and that's enough to demonstrate that a) game engine is bugged or b) game engine parameters need to be re-calibrated.

you have right,and the most games are judged badly by the engine!i have the best team from Romania and ??what?

Guys, please don't hijack this thread. This is a Q&A thread. You can talk about the engine somewhere else.

i have ,also the best players in defense,and is not good !

you have a very weird perception of what is a bad result. Many of the ones you tagged bad are pretty normal in soccer. There small number of goals in soccer make the sport very unpredictable. You should know that.