Время:

Ваша команда:
Общение
Public account
  Зона PRO
1330 кредитов
Купить кредиты
Вы в общественном аккаунте. Если вы хотите начать игру или присоединиться к обсуждению, то вам нужно войти. Если же вы новичок, то сначала вам нужно зарегистрироваться.

  Тема: Discussion about the importance of the DF stat for forwards


Владелец PRO пакета Канада SamuelCarrier

Hey guys,

So I've been training more the defensive stat of some of my forwards lately to make them my defensive specialists for PK duties. And something interesting has happened: All those guys became my top scorers, outscoring some more highly skilled players or at least matching their performances.

Most of my offense comes from my first 2 lines. Here is the breakdown with OR rating,df rating and total points in parentheses.

1st line:
Sutton (1761, DF 38, 34 in 12)
Lachaeu (1897, DF 57, 38 in 15)
Doerner (2086, DF 20, 37 in 15)

2nd line:
Guay (1806, DF 21, 24 in 12)
Bekes (1695, DF 101, 36 in 15)
Hart (2044, DF 57, 37 in 15)

One mitigating factor is that, unless I have a training camp going on, ice time is usually equally spread between my different lines. However, lines 3 and 4 get the same icetime as others (except for less opportunities on special units in most cases and worse linemates). Also, most of them are very close together and the sample size is probably too small to make up any real conclusion.

BUT, all of them are around 3 PPG except for Guay who is at 2. However, Guay is more offensive skilled than Sutton, but got much worse statline. Both play with linemates with around the same number of points.

Bekes is the worst offensive player on his line, but he gets a high PPG. Doerner is the best offensive player on his line, but scored one less than Lachaeu, the defensive specialist (however difference might be too small to draw conclusions here).

Now, I am mostly curious to know if any of you have seen such a pattern before. I am tempted to train defensively all my offensive players (who have decent Qs for it) to see if it affects the game as much as I think it might.

It makes sense to me that by playing good defensively they create more turnovers and more offensive opportunities. By that logic spending some training time on defense would actually improve the overall performance, and offensive one as well.

Before spending too many ressources there, I want to see if this pattern has been noticed elsewhere before.


Владелец PRO пакета Канада SamuelCarrier

To clarify, I find especially interesting that Bekes is the worst offensive forward in my top 6 (I have crappy depth at center) but he hangs with the big dogs as best scorers while Guay is doing worse even though he is a better offensive player by a good margin.


tescosamoa

I have noticed it in soccer, not hockey. Overall control of the ball. There are a few of us who train a little extra.


praxin


This is a Scott question but he’s playing with penguins right now. If I remember correctly Defense on offensive players does very little to help in hockey. In soccer I try to train a second main to around 100 ( mid 655 off 100 or def 655 and mid 100.. but I do it cause there are caps to attributes and may have heard having a mid with offence and defence trained actually help overall rating for all three positions. This is just what my brain remembers


Владелец PRO пакета Канада Bobby Jay

I too believe there is "some benefit" in hockey to training offense on defense and defense on offence. I also believe there is "some benefit" to training centres on aggression, wingers on passing, and for sure defense on technique. I say "some benefit" because generally, I only do this where their training percentages in those areas are high enough to warrant it so that long periods are not spent training those players with lower training percentages for the qualities in question.
The same can be said for my soccer team.


BigDaddyB

Good morning from Eastern Canada, Happy New Year! I have a request from the population. Is anyone interested in designing the complete uni, puck and pennants for both my teams, hockey and handball. Appreciate all responses. Have a great day.


Krokador

What my observations have been to this day, and this is without looking at the actual attributes of the players:

LW will score more goals on any given line
RW tend to have more assists than both LW and C
Cs will have more passes than both W, but also more goals than RW (hence why training shooting on center is ALSO important)

[Funnily enough, the R vs L balance seems to be the other way around in handball. Go figure]

But now I feel like I need to go dig into my team's stats from last season (this season doesn't count. I can't even score 1 playing VH vs H against a team with like 30 OR more than I. On the other hand, teams with OR 150 lower than me would be able to get 3 goals vs me, though. Ugh!)

Yep. I mean the stats are a bit skewed for sure (Not all players got equal play time against opponents of much lower strength.), but the overall trend is as described earlier for both season 27 and 28. This season I think I have a total of like 20 goals so far, so like I said, the stats don't apply lol.

So it may not be your player's attributes as much as the order in which the game decides who makes a shot.

NOW, someone please look at our NT's 20yo goalies, Craddock and Gagne, and explain to me how Craddock consistenly has better numbers that Gagne, even though his goalie stats are a bit lower. Is it the 80 in defense? *dun dun dun*


Krokador

Sorry, little correction to above post: RW will have more passes than LWs, but more goals than Cs, while getting overall a bit less points total than both other forward positions


Leafsdude

I train my forwards on defense (and my defensemen on offense) to 100, mostly just because I like round numbers, though I do train some guys to 70% of the base attribute for special teams as well. I don't worry too much about doing it because I know training my guys to the optimal numbers is not going to give me much better players. When I'm maxed for training, I might change it at least for my A-squad guys. The biggest reason why it's not a good idea would be because it'd just be another quality attribute that would need to be high. Bobby Jay gives a good thought in that, if you have a player who is high in the relevant attributes but also has good defense (or whatever) qualities, it's probably not a bad idea to give some extra training to them, but trying to build a team with such a system is probably going to end in nothing but heartbreak, since picking up 17 players who fit would be near impossible without breaking the bank, let alone 40.

As for actual results, I've noticed very little in terms of surprises compared to other results around the game (I do get upsets, but usually they happen with matched tactics). The one thing, however, is I very rarely lose to teams I should beat based on team average, but then most teams with lesser ORs tend to be poor at matching tactics (hell, even some teams with higher ORs are terrible), so giving a good guess on the relevance of such training will always extremely hard.


Krokador

I have another point to make. While overall position attributes are important, I think I've had enough games like this one:
hockey.powerplaymanager.c...

where I dominate on shooting, play 2 notches higher in importance and the average OR isn't *that* different... yet still can't score a *&*&?*& goal...

That shooting is importanter.

(I've had a really good sample size with the last 2 WC runs of the U20 team, too).

Train shooting, folks. :-X


Владелец PRO пакета Канада SamuelCarrier

well it took a little while to get answers on this thread, but it didn't disappoint. Lots of interesting impressions have been shared. It all basically seems to boil down to this though: nobody knows for sure.

Like Bobby, I only train it if the Q is good for it. I guess I kinda decided that I would train some guys for the purpose of eventually selling on the market (I only train them in the usual optimal setting of 2-1-1 and shooting/technique) and some players I would train for purposes of being on my team and I would try some slightly different approaches there.

I guess there are way too many variables here to isolate only this one and know for sure if it affects the game or not. Although it probably does somewhat... the question is... do these extra points of D for a fwd impact the game more than the same points distributed in other categories would? I guess that is too complicated of a question to get a definite answer to.



Избранные темы
Словакия Športová akad...
Словакия I.1
Словакия Kšefty-Tímy-Z...
Сербия Репрезентациј...
Босния и Герцеговина Vicevi
Словакия II.4
Польша Reprezentacja...
Словакия Hlásenie chýb
Словакия Okamžite výzv...
Словакия Futbal vo sve...
Словакия MS U20, U18
Сербия II.1
Словакия kredity
Словакия Nové športy
Словения U17
Чехия II.1
Словакия Nezobrazuje m...
Босния и Герцеговина Novi sport na...
Болгария младежи
Бразилия Amistosos Sta...
Бразилия PPMbet
Словения Bodoče zvezde...
Алжир I.1
Бразилия Esportes
Польша Poszukuję Asy...
Босния и Герцеговина Prevodioci
Бразилия OFF - Cartola...
Польша Ski Jump Mani...
Бразилия Condolences
Чехия Platy hráčů u...
Босния и Герцеговина BiH PP Magazi...
Алжир المنتخب الجزا...
Алжир اجتماع بيع لا...
Алжир كرة اليد على ...
Алжир كرة القدم الج...
Алжир عصبة الاندية ...
Бразилия Uniformes e L...
Босния и Герцеговина koga bi vi
Босния и Герцеговина Popularizacij...
Босния и Герцеговина Prognoziranje...
Босния и Герцеговина Veliki događa...
Эстония MM Eestisse
Бразилия Sports Rankin...
Босния и Герцеговина Sastanak BH Z...
Египет سؤال وجواب في...
Босния и Герцеговина PPM Kredit
Австрия Tennis Duel -...
Бельгия financien
Бельгия Vanalles
Азербайджан PPM Translato...
Австрия Facebook
Босния и Герцеговина Facebook
Австрия 2. Mannschaft...
Австрия Jerseys?
Алжир مقابلة ودية ب...
Азербайджан U-17 milli ko...
Босния и Герцеговина Sms krediti
Словакия Kohutko Cup I...
Словакия Gold Cup
Словакия Trh hráčov/za...
Словакия National Gree...
Словакия V.168
Словакия players for G...
Словакия Pravidla (Ad ...
Словакия 2 zapasy za d...
Словакия postup?
Словакия Ligový pohár
Словакия dresy a vlajk...
Словакия National Germ...
Словакия PPM reprezent...
Словакия Voľby trénera...
Словакия DB National I...
Словакия PPZT:pred a p...
Словакия HANDBALL MANA...
Словакия F1
Словакия tranfers
Австралия New F1 manage...
Словакия organizujem t...
Словакия transfer
Словакия Dresy
Словакия VI.188
Словакия VI.190
Словакия VI.196
Словакия VI.185
Словакия VI.177
Словакия VI.184
Словакия VI.178
Словакия VI.180
Словакия VI.166
Словакия VI.172
Словакия VI.168
Словакия VI.169
Словакия VI.170
Словакия VI.173
Словакия VI.164
Словакия VI.163
Словакия VI.127
Словакия V.85
Словакия VI.111
Словакия VI.72
Словакия VI.109
Словакия Futbalová Rep...
Словакия V.253
Словакия Slovakia Cup ...
Словакия VI.113
Словакия Esox lucius f...
Словакия trgu - trensf...
Словакия V.160
Словакия Klubové vlajk...
Словакия Vytvorenie kl...
Словакия V.248
Словакия VI.143
Словакия VI.146
Словакия V.170
Словакия V.232
Словакия Žilinska fotb...
Словакия V.252
Словакия V.255
Словакия V.247
Словакия VI.96
Словакия V.223
Словакия VI.9
Словакия Kto ma najvac...
Словакия V.230
Словакия V.133
Словакия VI.147
Словакия V.184
Словакия uspesnost str...
Словакия VI.126
Словакия VI.58
Словакия VI.51
Беларусь "Клубная супе...
Словакия V.158 tipovač...
Словакия V.250
Словакия VI.80
Словакия mini champion...
Словакия V.249
Словакия V.229
Словакия V.251
Словакия Primera Divis...
Словакия Tímový web
Словакия VI.160
Словакия Friendly Matc...
Словакия VI.156
Словакия Klubovy web
Словакия V.127
Словакия Futbalova Rep...
Словакия Taktiky
Словакия Tréning hráčo...
Словакия SVK Repre - F...
Словакия VI.145
Словакия Stažnosti na ...
Словакия VI.106
Словакия futbal
Словакия Design-logo-d...
Словакия V.208
Словакия V.189
Словакия stadio
Словакия VI.149
Словакия VI.125
Словакия VI.88
Словакия V.176
Словакия SILA TÍMU
Словакия VI.103
Словакия V.148
Словакия super zápasy
Словакия Ponuky generá...
Словакия Slovenské Sup...
Словакия V.148
Словакия stavanie záze...
Словакия Tipovacia súť...
Словакия V.172
Словакия pro evolution...
Словакия Corgoň liga a...
Словакия VI.138
Словакия 2x zaspievaná...
Словакия Tvorba Loga
Словакия A.C.A.B. CUP
Словакия Najlepší stre...
Словакия Šlapak
Словакия V.201
Словакия VI.154
Словакия VI.142
Словакия Horna nitra C...
Словакия VI.148
Словакия VI.97
Словакия VI.144
Словакия Súťaž o 40 kr...
Словакия VI.112
Словакия MS vo Futbale...
Словакия kupovanie zam...
Словакия Hlasovanie - ...
Словакия V.242
Словакия Priatelsky du...
Словакия ZAPASY PRIJMA...
Словакия PPMliga-turna...
Словакия Tvorba-loga-d...
Словакия Majstrovstvá ...
Словакия V.178
Словакия IV.24 Ligové ...
Словакия VI.128
Словакия VI.54
Словакия Turnaj - UEFA...
Словакия Turnaj - Prem...
Словакия Liga majstrov
Словакия VI.110
Словакия V.146
Австралия Last Letter -...
Словакия V.256
Словакия VI.114
Словакия V.225
Словакия VI.92
Словакия V.246
Словакия V.239
Словакия V.237
Австрия Regeln/Rules
Новые сообщения